Cast from the Garden

Youssef Rakha on the hotel apartment for The National

From the hotel apartment, you confront the frustrations of a society that is home enough, but will never feel like home – a society that is seemingly modelled on the hotel apartment. Andrew Parsons / The National

———-

With the laundry dangling behind his back, the podgy bell boy slid in. He was fast and noiseless, his arms so laden above his bald head you could barely make out the raven’s wing of hair bobbing in its wake. I had barely closed the door when he finished arranging the laundry in the cupboard. Then, turning dramatically, he placed the flat of his hand on his heart: “This last time, Sir?” Blinking at the badge on his chest – Ramee Garden Hotel Apartments, it said: RG for short – I had to stifle my tears as I realised that, yes, this was the last load of laundry my favourite RG employee would bring in. My term at the hotel apartment, that Emirati speciality, was coming to an end.

So I reclined and recalled my first impressions on moving in there, directly on arrival in Abu Dhabi. Aside from the seemingly seedy all-male gatherings on the pavements outside, the seemingly idle staff populating a very sparsely furnished reception area and the seemingly shoddy aspect of the establishment as whole, the most striking thing was the emptiness. An emptiness compounded by awareness of yourself and others actually living there: in the kitchenette there was a cooker, a flat-screen TV, a bedside lamp. But I had not chosen them and I could not replace or supplement them because I knew I would not be staying for very long.

Still, bidding the bell boy farewell, now, I was truly sorry to be going. Unlike a hotel room, the hotel apartment is a place you grow attached to – however negative your first impressions. Not just because you end up staying there for so much longer (nearly four months, in my case): something about the way you occupy the space strikes a near perfect balance. You use the cooker, but only to make Turkish coffee, for which the small purchase of a coffee pot has proven necessary. But you neither enjoy nor really care about enjoying the privilege.

Unlike an apartment, the hotel apartment does not bog you down with responsibilities; enough of you is there to make it yours – your clothes, your food, your books and DVDs, your bathroom implements – but there is none of the daily upkeep, the self-enclosure, the long-term investment or the sense of belonging associated with your own place.

The hotel apartment is a makeshift home, with a surrogate, changeable family of occasionally-helpful staff to go with it. Like an apartment building, it has neither lobby nor room service. But unlike it, it involves appliances you do not have to pay for, a contactable reception that will send up a bell boy every time you ring, regardless of what you ask for, and a sloppy cleaning service (on demand). It combines the best or worst of both worlds, speaking eloquently to those genes responsible for being on the move, en route, a tireless traveller – or Bedu.

In this way hotel apartments tell a profound truth about the Emirates: that it is essentially a country of nomads. Yet the white-collar Bedu they house – far from the all but extinct local camel herders – are the bourgeois equivalent of migrant labour, requiring shower, satellite TV and many modern life necessities the hotel apartment does not always or adequately provide. In hotel apartments there lives a variously disgruntled range of wage slaves seeking oil-opened opportunities, however unrelated their line of work to oil.

On these bare floors, behind doors with broken handles, in bathrooms where the dirty towels were removed never to be replaced, up and down talking lifts – “Sorry to keep you waiting”, “Going down” – and in conversation with characterful locals (in as much as anyone here is local), people live out the first – sometimes only – few months of their stay. It is here that they discover the language (or lack thereof), the weather, the contents of the corner shops and the attitudes of their keepers. It is here that they develop a cartography of their daily life: the main road, the taxi rank, the office and, further afield, the sea. From the hotel apartment, and in it, they confront the frustrations of a society that is home enough, but will never feel like home – a society that is seemingly modelled on the hotel apartment.

Even when you have moved into a flat, even when you have brought over your family or – a far less frequent occurrence, this – started a family, so long as you are in the Emirates the hotel apartment shadow will hang over you. I have my own living space now, but I do not feel more settled. If anything, the tension between having a home and remaining, to all intents and purposes, under hotel apartment conditions, has generated a sense of confusion. That confusion is two-fold.

On the one hand, I already miss my RG bell boy, the sense of community generated by things breaking down and Maintenance being summoned to fix them, the random encounters on the way in and out, and conversations, notably about The National, with reception staff. I miss the always changing noises that would trickle in from the adjoining room at the weirdest hours: food for all kinds of fantastical scenarios about similarly displaced people living in hotel apartments, the toing and froing between rooms, Indian voices announcing a visitor downstairs. But on the other hand, with a flat to my name, with furniture I chose and TV channels I personally subscribed to, I am being tricked into believing that I really do live in the Emirates.

I would happily give in to the trick – except it undermines the one thing I have come to value about living here: that sense of being indefinitely in transit. This is why I was sorry to leave RG: that state of transience, the wonderfully liberating lack of commitment you experience under hotel-apartment conditions is no longer embodied by my living space.

It is this that sets the Gulf apart, though: it draws in people from all over the world. They are here to work and so forced to stay here, but they feel no genuine attachment to the place. Their relationship with the surroundings, other people, the landscape is rather like mine to my RG kitchenette cooker. And living thus, they become nomads of the future: a globalised workforce constantly hopping about to wherever their professional responsibilities post them, and likely forced to stay in some kind of hotel apartment.

Roots have been planted in the Emirates, but being emphatically foreign, however old they grow, they remain the roots of a nomad: flexible, shallow and incapable of spreading. Homes are but the portable tents of a mind seeking greener pastures – forever. And no matter how much people complain of this, especially Arabs, there is a high value in it. People speak of the insecurity induced by having no citizenship, by dependence on an employment contract and inability, in any genuine sense, to settle down. Certainly few people like to stay in a hotel apartment for too long, whether they are citizens or not.

But there is something it means to be in the Emirates – as a non-citizen, on a contract, knowing that, sooner or later, you will (be made to) leave – and that thing, whatever else it does to you, can invest life with an excitement more abiding and deeper than that of a mere stint abroad, or a journey. People should appreciate their stay in a real hotel apartment both because it prepares them for long-term life in this country and because, predicament or blessing, it remains the most articulate metaphor for being in the Gulf.

Reblog this post [with Zemanta]

One thought on “Cast from the Garden

  1. Excellent essay about the hotel apartment. Amazingly, no one before you has written about this odd lifestyle of sorts that seems truly unique to the Gulf region. I spent a good deal of time in Dubai from 2001-07, much of it in 3 or 4 hotel apartments my company rented for our rotating cast of engineers coming from the States (some of us more than others).

    The coworkers who had been there before me would leave behind their Texas-sized shisha pipes, 6-packs of beer, and food in the cupboard, and I would do the same as we rotated between the US and Dubai every few weeks depending on our project needs. Plus my departing cohorts would carefully leave for me on the bed pillow the occasional “note” from “Svetlana from Belarus” and assorted Russian and other ex-Soviet businesswomen/entertainers as found in the various Bur Dubai hotel bars.

    In those years, there was no wi-fi in the apartment, so the hangout for me away from work became the “internet cafe” down the street, which was the one place after hours and late at night I could catch up with home while enjoying a burger, kebab or pomegranate juice. The downstairs folks in the reception area would be comfortably familiar as would be the breakfast buffet, with its weird combination of western, pan-Asian, European and Indian cuisine (fried eggs with miso soup, masala, tomatoes and french fries anyone?). The TV, depending on the day, might receive CNN, BBC, between 3 and 8 Indian music channels, some weird Arabian single-girls channel, a sports station with bad reception, and 2 or 3 local Gulf stations, including the infamous “Channel 33″ (now the ever hip Dubai One). Amazingly, each year there would magically be one station that would show the Super Bowl (even if it was 5 am in Dubai).

    Over time as the decade wore on and I got more locally connected, I would have a company SUV and would spent much time away from the apartment, whether on the job site, being invited to the air show or other events, or visiting Dubai’s growing array of attractions, malls, beaches and watering holes, as well as on occasion its still-charming old souk areas. I also had built up a cadre of expat friends that I would spend time with. The hotel apartment with no wi-fi, 10-year old TV, industrial-looking kitchen, and flat bed with stiff pillows and itchy blanket became a strange but charming anachronism in a city which by 2004 was quickly becoming more modern and advanced than my home base in the Washington DC area. In a strange way, it was that little reminder that no matter how much I try to make myself at home, I’m not really home.

    In contrast, I’ve been coming to Abu Dhabi off and on now for 18 months, strictly staying in hotels with full Internet access, overpriced restaurants, and high quality gyms, and doing much less exploring. (Quite honestly, even with Abu Dhabi’s swift growth in the last 5 years, there’s a lot less to explore than there is in Dubai.) But now I get comfortable beds just like in the nice US hotels, a sea view, and instant (for a price) Internet access. And I now even have my own local smartphone instead of a borrowed low-end office mobile phone like the old days. Ironically, many of my old colleagues have changed jobs as I have over the years, and find themselves in Abu Dhabi often since it has supplanted Dubai as the money-and-job magnet for engineers. So ironically, I still have many of my old friends, older and perhaps wiser than we were in Dubai. But it is different, after all. Before, we felt like strangers who were together building paradise. Now we feel like strangers in some kind of paradise, but not of our own making.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s